TRAVEL
Great Canadian RIVERS 
History 
Ecosystem 
Culture 
Recreation 
Economy 

 
ThreeRiversHistory

Shipbuilding Shores
Axes swinging, hammers ringing, pay packets swelling - at the time of Canadian Confederation in 1867, shipbuilding was the leading producer of wealth on Prince Edward Island. From felling trees and sawing lumber, to fashioning blocks and pulleys, splicing ropes, caulking seams and sewing sails, the shipbuilding boom created thousands of jobs. It contributed not only to the “Golden Age of Sail,” but also to an era of plenty and prosperity. By 1850, the Three Rivers area boasted 11 of the Island’s 50 shipyards, steadily turning out vessels from the villages of Cardigan, Montague and Georgetown. By the time the age of steam took over – and many of the Island’s forests had disappeared –Three Rivers’ shipyards had launched over 400 ships.

Spacious Cardigan Bay, sheltered between Boughton and Panmure Islands, was a natural location for shipbuilding operations, and Cardigan Wharf, at the mouth of the Cardigan River, became a shipbuilding centre and cargo port. Throughout Three Rivers, ship launches became a frequent source of community entertainment. Among the largest ships produced were the Willie McLaren (1874), the Matilda (1892), and the Empress schooner, Montague’s record-breaker (1901). In Georgetown Harbour, famous ships included the Victoria (1841), the Alma (1870), the Aquila (1888) and the Lady Napier (1902).

The fortunes of the Three Rivers shipbuilders reflected the rise and fall of the industry around the Island. From a peak of 914 vessels in the years 1861-1870, total Island production declined to 571 from 1871-1880, 137 from 1881-90, and 52 from 1891-1900. The last sailing ships launched in Cardigan Bay were a trio of schooners, the Victory Chimes, the Anne MacDonald and the Barbara MacDonald. Both the Anne and the Barbara sailed through violent weather, and in 1924, the Barbara’s crew was lost at sea.

The Ice Boat Tragedy of 1885
Just 5 metres long and barely 2 metres wide, Prince Edward Island’s unassuming, tin-covered 19th century ice boats were a welcome sight to the stranded passengers of winter ferries caught in the ice between Georgetown and Pictou on the Nova Scotia mainland. The open craft, equipped with runners, sails and straps for hauling, were designed to glide over solid ice and slip easily into open water. As rescue craft, they were often called in to take food and supplies to ferry crews, and carry passengers back to port.

Mail Run: In prolonged subzero weather, when ferry icebreakers could not navigate the frozen expanse of Northumberland Strait, ice boats were the only source of transportation to the mainland. Their service was provided under government contract, and conveyance of mail was regarded as their most important function. Passengers were something of an afterthought. Those who were willing to help the crew haul the boat were able to travel for free, but riders paid a steep fare. Tightly-negotiated contracts left ice boat captains with little money left for safety equipment, and the crossing of the Strait could be fraught with hardship and danger.

Failed Ferries: Year-round ferry service between the Island and the mainland – the provision of “continuous and efficient communication” – was a highly controversial issue in post-Confederation Prince Edward Island. Endeavoring to keep its promise to the Islanders (at the lowest possible cost), the federal government hired a private winter steamship operator from Georgetown. When his ship, the Albert, was unable to navigate the ice for 2 winters in a row, the government pressed an aging and inadequate icebreaker, the Northern Light, into service. Over a period of 12 years, the ill-fated steamship spent more time stalled and stuck than free and floating – to the delight of political humourists, the ship’s crew had discovered that its stern was more effective than its stem in breaking through the ice. Business was brisk for the Island’s ice boats.

In 1881, ice boat crews were forced to make several dramatic rescues of impatient ferry passengers who, confined to the mainland for three weeks in row, set out to walk across the Strait. Their desperation added to the Islander’s angry pleas for reliable year-round ferry service.

Northumberland Nightmare:
On January 27, 1885, no one came to the rescue of the ice boats themselves, when they were caught in a sudden, blinding snowstorm in the middle of Northumberland Strait. The crew of 15, along with 7 passengers, were forced to camp overnight on the ice under the shelter of 2 upturned boats and some luggage. A third boat was burned for heat, but it did little to lessen the effects of wildly plunging temperatures. There was no food, no water and no extra clothing or survival gear. On the following day, the frozen, snow-blinded, near-delirious group struggled on, finally collapsing on a drift-covered marsh close to shore. Those still standing managed to reach a nearby home. Although no one died in the tragedy, some lost their hands and feet to frostbite, and the Islander’s impatience with the federal government turned to rage.

The ice boat tragedy set the stage for an improvement in ice boat safety regulations, and the eventual improvement of the winter ferry fleet. After flirting with an ambitious plan to build a “Northumberland Tunnel” on the floor of the sea between the Island and the mainland, the federal government commissioned a more substantial ice breaker, the Stanley. It was followed by the Minto and the Earl Grey, and finally, in 1914, by the ice breaking car ferry, the Prince Edward Island.

Three Rivers Heritage at Garden of the Gulf Museum
Shipbuilding exhibits, First Nations artifacts, early household items and the history of the 18th century Roma Settlement are all part the collection of the Garden of the Gulf Museum, located on the Montague River in the town of Montague. The Museum, housed in a former federal post office and customs building, maintains a collection of over 2500 objects relating to the heritage of the Three Rivers area.

Roma’s Doom
Was it just a coincidence that Jean Pierre de Roma’s pioneering Prince Edward Island settlement lasted for 13 years? The unlucky number seems to symbolize the bad luck and misfortune that befell one of the Islands’ first communities.

Vaunted Vision: In 1731, the ambitious and somewhat grandiose Paris merchant was appointed director of the “Compagne de L’Est de L’Île Saint-Jean,” under charter of King Louis XV of France. The Company was granted a feudal estate on the eastern part of the island in an area bordered by the Cardigan, Brudenell and Montague Rivers.

Under the terms of the charter, Roma and his Company were required to settle 80 people in 1732, and 30 people each year thereafter. The settlement, known as “Trois Rivières” (and sometimes “La Romaine”), was intended to be a commercial fishing operation. But Roma and his French business partners envisioned more. Their plan was to trade cod, planks and beer for molasses and rum from the West Indies, which they would sell to Quebec in exchange for supplies such as flour.

For the first few years Roma and his settlers made astonishing progress. At Brudenell Point they cleared land, built piers, dug wells, constructed 9 homes and outbuildings, planted fields of wheat and peas, set out gardens, and built a number of small boats. Over the course of 2 winters, a crew of 19 men braved the snow and cold to construct a series of narrow, rudimentary roads to St. Peter’s, Sturgeon River, Cardigan, Souris and Port-La-Joie (Charlottetown). In St. Peter’s, Roma established a satellite fish-drying operation, complete with housing drying platforms and housing for 55 people.

Growing Misfortune:
But Roma’s luck suddenly ran out. Under pressure from his Paris partners, he was forced to become the Company’s sole proprietor. Headstrong and willful, Roma quarreled with the settlement’s priest over the division of sacred and secular powers. His labour pool shrank, as new immigrants chose to follow their own destinies rather than join the feudal enterprise. In 1738, an ominous plague of mice ruined the settlement’s crops. In 1740, fire destroyed some his buildings and cattle, and in 1741, one of the Company’s sea-going vessels was shipwrecked. Finally, in 1745, just as Roma faced financial ruin, British troops from New England attacked and destroyed Tros Rivières. Roma, his family and his servants fled first to the woods, and then to Quebec.

Roma, whose reputation for fractiousness was well-established, never returned to Île Saint-Jean, despite the island’s temporary re-assignment to the French. In 1757, as the drama of the fall of Louisbourg and the deportation of the Acadians was played out on the east coast, Roma headed south to an administrative post on the island of Martinique.

Lasting Legacy: When Roma’s Trois Rivières settlement was excavated in the late 1960’s, archeologists found only a couple of half-filled wells and some remnants of masonry. But while little remains of the settlement’s bricks and mortar, Roma’s vision of the Three Rivers area as a centre of industry and commerce was eventually realized by the fishers, farmers and shipbuilders of the following century.

Today, visitors to the Three Rivers area can view the Roma of Three Rivers National Historic Monument on Brudenell Point at the junction of the Montague and Brudenell Rivers.